Ethics Information

Enron's Ultimate Victim: Ethics


FROM the 'MORAL HIGH GROUND', where we imagine ourselves, the Enron fiasco should have come as no surprise. Enron is simply a quintessential example of the degradation of principles such as trust, loyalty and ethical standards.

Why it happened,however,is what really needs to be understood if business is to restore its ethical foundation and survive tumultuous times.

Few will argue that business today is more challenging and competitive; most everyone accepts that the marketplace is more cutthroat than ever. We live in a dog-eat-dog world where for most, corporate survival is focused on just trying to not get eaten.

Not long ago, things were not so ruthless, or so we'd like to think. Companies had a tacit understanding with their employees: the company will always be there for you. The expression, "I'm a company man," once represented the unquestioned relationship between employees and employer. The company was our family, and families looked out for one another. Anything less was considered disloyal and unacceptable.

The 1990s ushered in changes that still exist today. The 90's also started us on the slippery slope that altered the ground rules for ethics and basic corporate loyalty. Call it downsizing, rightsizing or realigning, but dedicated employees suddenly found themselves on the outs with new, supposedly competitive, corporate initiatives that were sold as necessary to keep companies viable. Keeping viable sometimes meant severing long-serving employees, who were left disillusioned, betrayed and often unarmed to fend for themselves.

Pre-1990, the downsizing of corporate workforces was inconscionable. Companies had an obligation to look after their people, didn't they? Apparently, they didn't. The targets of the realignment strategies were the suddenly "overpriced," tenured employees. Survival strategies were designed to replace higher-income staff (in reality, those who had given the most to the company) with less experienced workers to reduce payroll expenditures.

Cuts in tenured staff were easy to justify providing you bought into the argument that older employees were redundant, i.e., bereft of computer skills. There was some legitimacy to this, but therein lies one of the clearest examples of expediency and cost-cutting prevailing over loyalty and ethics.

It was train existing staff or replace them with young techno-grads at half the price. History demonstrates the route most companies took. It also marked the beginning of the separation of trust between employees and their companies. There is little loyalty left.

Today, employees lucky enough to have outlived the 90's occupy many of the corner offices on the executive floors. Those who write the cheques and run the companies are the surviving veterans of the last decade, well-trained in guerilla management now unfettered by moral obligations for traits such as loyalty or ethics.

This is not to cast aspersions upon today's executives but to show how "Enronesque" outcomes can result when industries abandon components essential to sustaining moral values.

Ethics and morality have taken a backseat in business, and there is no greater example than the outgoing settlement cheques being issued to Enron execs. At the same time, 20- and 30-year Enron employees are losing their entire retirement portfolios.

Executives cannot be held totally to blame. They are victims themselves, the byproduct of those well-trained in the new business religion. Most new executive contracts include a Parachute Clause, insurance against the executive or company who wants to part ways. The practice is ethical but, in my opinion, another example of a breakdown in loyalty. It all but promotes failure.

Parachute Planning is analogous to a prenuptial. The purpose and logic is understood. The facts speak for themselves. I read recently that reported 98.9 per cent of prenup-weddings in North America fail within three years. From another perspective, it appears there are now tangible rewards for failure or disloyalty.

The Bottom Line:

Ethics, trust and loyalty are still there. Fundamental values have not changed. Companies who buck the "all-for-me" trend to garner respect and trust will benefit everyone, but it will take time.

About The Author

Author, corporate coach, international keynote speaker and president of Success 150 Group Inc., Suite 458, 7305 Woodbine Ave, Markham, Ont.L3R 3V7

T: 416-728-5556 / 1-866-855-4590

E: paul@success150.com

W: www.paulshearstone.com, http://www.success150.com


MORE RESOURCES:

USA TODAY

Dems keeping a close eye on GOP ethics cases
USA TODAY
Spencer Bachus, R-Ala., is the subject of an inquiry by the Office of Congressional Ethics. Rep. Spencer Bachus, R-Ala., is the subject of an inquiry by the Office of Congressional Ethics. The latest came Thursday when it was reported that the Office ...
Lawmaker's stock trades draw ethics investigationBoston.com
Speaker Boehner faces ethics dilemma with Bachus investigationThe Hill
Ethics panel looking at lawmaker's stock tradesCBS News
BusinessWeek
all 378 news articles »


Kansas City Star

Britain's media ethics inquiry: the story so far
CBS News
The first phase of Britain's media ethics inquiry ended this week after 40 days of dramatic hearings that heard from 184 witnesses _ celebrities, journalists, editors, academics and lawyers _ and revealed wildly differing perspectives on the murky ...
Staff at The Sun tabloid arrested in bribe inquirySeattle Post Intelligencer

all 219 news articles »


9NEWS.com

Ethics case dropped against Rep. Laura Bradford; she says she'll stick with GOP
Denver Post
By Lynn Bartels A 15-day uproar over a lawmaker's traffic stop ended Friday after her peers dismissed a drinking-related ethics complaint against the Mesa County Republican. Rep. Laura Bradford confirmed she wasn't switching parties, and House Speaker ...
Ethics Investigation Dropped In State Rep's Traffic StopKMGH Denver
Bradford ethics probe should go onCanon City Daily Record
Ethics panel to decide whether to continue review of Colo. lawmaker's traffic stopThe Republic
Fox 31 KDVR.com -Grand Junction Sentinel -KKCO-TV
all 28 news articles »


Jindal suggests ethics changes
The Daily Advertiser
Bobby Jindal has agreed with the Board of Ethics that some changes are needed to strengthen enforcement and clarify authority to enforce the Code of Ethics. But the governor's plans for change to be filed in the legislative session that starts March 12 ...
Jindal to put forth ethics law packageThe Advocate

all 5 news articles »


NewsNet5.com

Consultants suggest OSU hire ethics czar: College Notebook
Plain Dealer
By Plain Dealer wire services A report given to an Ohio State Board of Trustees' committee Thursday recommends that the university hire a vice president to oversee a new office and new committee responsible for monitoring ethics and rules compliance ...
Report says Ohio State needs ethics officeFox News
Report: Ohio State needs ethics officeESPN
Report: OSU needs VP for complianceIronton Tribune

all 406 news articles »


Lying to Patients: No Huge Ethical Failure, Says Bioethicist
Medscape
I am Art Caplan, and I am at the University of Pennsylvania in the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy. Today I would like to talk to you about a pretty thorny subject and one that is fascinating because it is so ethically rich: Should ...

and more »


CBS Local

Maryland Ethics Panel Suggests Reducing Local Disclosure
NBC4 Washington (blog)
By Brian Witte, AP A panel of state senators reviewing Maryland ethics rules decided Friday to recommend local government officials should not be required to release as much information in financial disclosure forms as officials in state government.
Md. panel reviewing changes to ethics rules for lawmakers to meetWashington Post
Bill would require online disclosureBaltimore Sun (blog)
Ethics panel suggests reducing local disclosureDaily Record (subscription)

all 21 news articles »


WABE

Watchdog groups demand more money for ethics board
Atlanta Journal Constitution
By Chris Joyner A coalition of watchdog groups said Friday cuts to the state ethics commission's budget have hobbled the agency and resulted in a backlog of unresolved complaints. Jason Getz, jgetz@ajc.com With the State Capitol in the background, ...
Advocates push for ethics fundingWABE

all 2 news articles »


Sen. Beavers and judges at odds over ethics panel
The Tennessean
AP A plan backed by Tennessee judges that would change the ethics panel that disciplines jurists is at odds with arguably the judiciary's biggest critic in the legislature — Sen. Mae Beavers. The differences in opinion came out this week at a debate ...
Beavers, judges still at oddsWDEF News 12

all 16 news articles »


MLive.com

Ficano revamps ethics policy
Detroit Free Press
Wayne County Executive Robert Ficano announces an ethics policy only for his appointees. / KATHLEEN GALLIGAN/Detroit Free Press By John Wisely Wayne County Executive Robert Ficano announced a new ethics policy Thursday, prohibiting actions such as ...
Wayne County Statement on ethics policyWDIV Detroit
Ficano to issue ethics reformsThe Detroit News
Ficano announces ethics reforms in wake of FBI probeMichigan Radio
The Republic
all 32 news articles »

Google News

home | site map
© 2006